Request pdf on mar 1, 2009, francis fukuyama and others published westernization vs. Westernization and modernization the railroad provided the ideal means to facilitate facetoface meetings. The slogan highlights the government efforts to encourage incremental change to integrate. And isnt modernization the same thing as westernization. Modernization versus westernization keys to understanding. This new platform, if carefully developed and rigorously implanted in the consciousness of the masses, could instantly clear up a number of dark spots in. It is the largest arab state west of asia by land area approximately 2,250,000 km2, constituting the bulk of the arabian peninsula commonly known as aljazeera. The chapter then examines the ideas of the african advocates of westernization, modernization, and liberal democracy. Difference between westernization and modernization. When we talk about modernization, it is often considered to be in hand with westernization.
Read does modernization mean westernization essay sample. Modernization consists of a gradual differentiation and specialization of social structures. The aim of this paper is to argue on modernization and westernization. Mar 25, 2002 globalization is often seen as global westernization. While walking through the hallways of a high school near the university where i teach, a set of posters hanging outside a classroom caught my attention. Mcgrathmartin, the modernization of the western world used 1st semester heilbroner, robert, the worldly philosophers marx, karl, and friedrich engels, the communist manifesto mcgrath, john, ed. Comparative analysis of westernization and modernization 2. They often attributed their global power to it, and thus their entitlement to have authority over other societies. Modernization and westernization are not the same thing. It is a thorough going process of change involving values, norms, institutions and structures. Huntington 1996 argues that modernization is not westernization, and to some extent, this is true since claiming that any country that is modernized, is westernized is depreciating other cultures. Ottoman expressions of early modernity and the inevitable. Jan 06, 2016 westernisation is a byproduct of our times.
Difference between modernization and westernization free. Faculty of cultural sciences of gadjah mada university. The westernization is less and less a proandcon issue, but rather requires a deeper reflection through the historical consciousness. From the opposite perspective, western dominance sometimes seen as a continuation of. Sanskritization and westernization economic and political. Although it has become common, especially in america, to conflate the three, f. Try out the html to pdf api popular posts essay modernization and westernization are not identical concepts person in news. Now the question comes, what should india strive forwesternization or modernization. Modernization is essential based on a rationalist and positive spirit. Let us realize at the outlet that the caste system is one of the most elaborate attempts at hierarchizafion of society ever undertaken by matt. Westernization and modernization are two ideologies that are under constant debate. Westernization deals with ideas, religion and culture. The basic assumption of this theory, in any of its versions, is that there is one general end page 157 process of which democratization is but the final stage. Some people have provided examples of taiwan and japan, which have accepted westernisation wholeheartedly as inevitable.
The idea that the west is better and therefore everyone else should emulate it still has strongly imperialist tendencies in which it is the white mans burden to engage in a civilising mission by compelling all the inferior culturesraces to conform to their own standards. Deepa kaushik 0514 india need to target on the positivity and better approach to step up the ladder of a tension free life for its citizens. The influence of westernization on nutrition and physical. Industrial revolution in england and to some extent, french revolution. Depending on which perspective it is either west or east the argument may last forever but to draw a line and separate the real ideologies can help solve the dilemma of whether the glass is half full or half empty. Arabia in view of the slogan modernization without westernization. This discourse persists to this day but in a slightly different form, namely the discourse of modernization and westernization. Reticence in the use of force as an instrument of state policy has been the dominant political condition for indian thinking on the military, including military. Modernization and westernization universiti utara malaysia. Modernization or westernization what should india target. When we talk about modernization, it is often considered to.
Using turkish and english sources, gurel maps the reaction of turks to the rise of the united states as a worldordering power in the twentieth century. The overall process of westernization is often twosided in that western influences and interests themselves are joined with parts of. The former concept revolves specifically around the spread of western ideas to other cultures influencing everything from morals to general. Liberalization, modernization, westernization joseph. Tuesday, 16 october 2012 essay modernization and westernization are not identical concepts introduction the battle between the east and the west still continues as each try to preserve its culture and assert its powers. As a venerable debate in development studies has framed the question.
Drezner modernization and westernization are not the same thing im going to go out on a limb and state unequivocally that i think civil liberties and. You rarely find a japanese, taiwanese or korean in. The posters had been drawn by students in a tenth grade world history class. Is there difference between westernization and modernization. Just as the fight to be superpowers continues, the west and east continue to outdo each other in other aspects. Ahead of indonesian independence in 1945, the discourse on cultural and ideological orientation by indonesian intellectuals became the foundation for the development of the nation. On this point, there is substantial agreement among many proponents and opponents. It is argued that if western oriented elites moved info africas elite vacuums, modernization can develop in the direction of western type valuenorm orientations. The 50% discount is offered for all ebooks and ejournals purchased on igi globals online bookstore. On the other hand, westernization mostly involves adopting the culture of. Political dimensions of modernization involves creation of a modern nation state and the development of key institutions.
Those who take an upbeat view of globalization see it as a marvelous contribution of western civilization to the world. Modernization without westernization the kingdom of saudi arabia was founded by abdulaziz bin saud in 1932, whose family name contributed to the name of the country. There does, however, exist a clear and distinct difference between the two notions that must be clarified before moving forward. Request pdf liberalization, modernization, westernization this paper distinguishes three distinct processes of change that a system of values can undergo.
Unlimited viewing of the articlechapter pdf and any associated supplements and. Contents introduction westernization westernization in india the end of the history modernization criteria of modernization the clash of the civilization comparison between modernization and westernization 3. As turkey transitioned from an empire to a nationstate, the. Like china and unlike japan, india resisted changes in its ancient beliefs about the way the world works and should work which modernization entails. Reticence in the use of force as an instrument of state policy has been the dominant political condition for indian thinking on the military, including military modernization.
Modernization is a process of sociocultural transformation. It has left its mark every where on indian life, but especial. Comparative analysis of westernization and modernization. The west seemed to be fascinating and the adoption of popular culture from the west, especially. Modernization without westernization should become the main slogan of a new course which should unite the best forces from both the conservative and reformist camps. Westernization and modernization strong winds of evangelicalism blew from london after 18, when the ban on missionary travel to and settlement in india was lifted. The progress in science and technology from the outside world created indonesia a market for western products. While westernization was penetrated only the upper level affecting mainly leisure class fashions, modernization today diffuses among a wider population and touches public institutions as well as private aspirations with its disquieting positive spirit. Unlimited viewing of the articlechapter pdf and any associated supplements and figures.
While westernization was penetrated only the upper level affecting mainly leisure class fashions, modernization today diffuses among a. The endogenous explanation is a modernization theory. Ebooks and ejournals are hosted on igi globals infosci platform and available for pdf andor epub download on a perpetual or subscription basis. What is globalization,modernization and westernization. This discount cannot be combined with any other discount or promotional offer. Modernization without westernization the fourth political. Modernization find, read and cite all the research you need on. These include some of the early west african nationalists of the late nineteenth century and early twentieth century, mostly westerneducated members of the west african elite such as james b. Modernization refers to the changes needed to esta. Modernization and westernization essay, essay get sample.
Modernization versus westernization the concept of modernity was an important rationale in projects of european imperialism, and is another element that sets this form of colonization apart from older forms of it. These are the principal theoretical explanations to interpret. Concept of modern, modernity and modernisation are tremendously notorious, mostly because of their ambiguity and vagueness. A critical analysis in the changing world situation after the post 1945 era, the development of modernization theory in order to modernise the rest of the world in line with american development is interestingly. Liberalization, modernization, westernization joseph heath. Since there are already many answers i will answer in short.
It is argued that if western oriented elites moved info africas elite vacuums, modernization can develop in. The industrial revolution, born in manchester in the last quarter of the. Modernisation has assumed a lot of significance particularly after the end of the second world war, in the 1950s and 1960s. What should india strive for westernization or modernization. Modernization is seen at the level of economics, as well as the ways in which these traditional approaches are subjected to clinical trials and then standardized, commodified, and mass distributedsuch as the curative use of artemesinin qing hao for malaria, and the controversial patent of the neem tree azadirachta indica for its medicinal properties figure 12. Liberalization, modernization, westernization joseph heath, 2004. These two terms are are westernization and modernization. Liberalization, modernization, westernization request pdf.
Westernization has been a growing influence across the world in the last few centuries, with some thinkers assuming westernization to be the equivalent of modernization, a way of thought that is often debated. Both modernization and westernization have their own pros and cons. Gurel explains this unique split and its echoes in contemporary u. Westernization is incorporation of the norms, values and culture of the west into our culture. Srinivas, westernization refers to the changes brought about in the indian society and culture as a result of over 150 years of. Whereas modernization entails a change in belief about the way the material world operates, westernization entails a change in cosmological beliefs about the way that one should live. Ppt on westernization and modernization showing 11 of 1 messages. Westernization westernization is a process in which societies adopt western cultures in areas such as industry, technology, law, politics, economies and lifestyles, clothing, language etc. It measures young peoples identification with western and indian ways of living. Therefore, this is not about modernizing just the economy alone but the society at large. Quite like sanskritisation the concept of westernisation is also employed for evaluating social change in rural india and elsewhere in the country. Westernisation implies that there is one path to achieve modernisation, but many would challenge that. Oct 20, 2017 westernization westernization is a process in which societies adopt western cultures in areas such as industry, technology, law, politics, economies and lifestyles, clothing, language etc.
According to conrad phillip, author of window on humanity, westerners will attempt to remake the 10 i. The westernization is less and less a pro and con issue, but rather requires a deeper reflection through the historical consciousness. Since a long time, there has been continuous conflict between the two terms. These questions are analysed with specific reference to certain nonwhite groups in south africa. Deepak lal f or the purposes of this essay, three types of liberty need to be distinguished. This is what causes resistance since a significant part of the population. We examined the process of individual socialization. Another mixture appears in the confusion of westernization with the modernization rozman, 1981.
It follows the same usage of reas on in the modernity. Modernization is limited to adoption of technology and industrialization. Westernization is a word that is gradually becoming synonymous with modernization. Modernization and westernization modernization involves urbanization. Sanskritization and westernization is a more dynamic one than even srinivas makes apparent in his writings. Article information, pdf download for liberalization, modernization, westernization. By the time the europeans launched an intensive drive to incorporate china at the beginning of the 1840s, the capitalist world economy was already completing the incorporation of other major new zones into its division of labour, most importantly, the indian subcontinent, the ottoman empire, the russian empire, and west africa. Difference between modernization and westernization free essays. The modernization of the western world during the first semester, we concentrated on social science methodology and learned some basic concepts fundamental to understanding human behavior and social structures. Both of the terms are affecting india, especially, its youth. Globalization is often seen as global westernization. While the kingdom of saudi arabia ksa aspires to educate, socially and politically motivate, and economically mobilize the citizens of the country, there is a slogan modernization without westernization which has received much attention in many countries, including saudi arabia e. They often attributed their global power to it, and thus their entitlement to.
64 359 252 706 69 1209 1167 454 348 75 904 404 1137 400 1145 430 1030 1392 800 929 232 103 1101 1072 956 383 790 750 1286 1449 532 1307 984 1172 1046 521 1285 705 771 1292 775 876 1445